The importance of independent
certification for product evaluation - Truth in
advertising:
There are many thousands
products on the market that claim to provide you, the consumer, with purest
water available, everything from filtration systems and distillation units to
bottled water. There are, for example, over 2,500 different water filters
on the market.
How do you evaluate competing, often
contradictory, statements and determine which claims are accurate and which
advertisements are nothing more than creative writing. When purchasing
health related products, creative advertising can be expensive for the
consumer, not to
mention downright dangerous. An improperly maintained water filter can
actually incubate trapped bacteria and release them into the "filtered" water.
I personally believe that a product's performance as well as the
accuracy of its advertising literature should be tested and certified by an
independent and disinterested third party. If a product is certified by a
reputable company you can be assured that a product's ads are not misleading and
the product will perform as specified.
Two organizations provide independent certification for water purification
devices, NSF
International and the Water
Quality Association (WQA). Underwriters
Laboratories (UL) is also beginning to certify water treatment systems.
The WQA has developed a Gold Seal program to help consumers choose quality water
treatment products. The WQA tests prototype water
treatment equipment, and awards the Gold Seal only to those systems
that have met or exceeded industry standards for contaminant reduction
performance, structural integrity, and materials safety.
NSF International is a group
that certifies water treatment systems, distillation units, bottled water, water
softeners, and a number of other food preparation systems. NSF
certification means that not only do the products perform as tested, the product
advertisements are also evaluated for accuracy and truthfulness. Products
are tested on an ongoing basis to make certain that companies continue to
produce products that perform as advertised.
You need to be aware
that there are a number of different NSF standards and different levels of
compliance within the standards. NSF certification does not mean
much unless you know exactly what a specific certification standard stands
for. A water filter certified to meet NSF Standard 42 Class II for taste,
odor and chlorine and Class II for particulate matter is not equivalent to a
filter certified to meet NSF Standard 42 Class I for taste, odor and chlorine
and Class I for particulate matter and Standard No. 53 for Health Effects.
The latter filter will remove a far wider range of contaminants -- and
will also probably cost 10 times as much as the former.
You will also
find, if you research water purification devices or bottled water, that many
companies state on their literature "Tested to NSF standards".
Tested by who? How often? Who backs up that claim? I
just visited a web site that advertised their water filter as tested and
certified in accordance with NSF/ANSI standards 42 and 53 (the NSF
logo was even displayed). I then checked the NSF on-line site
and neither the company nor the filter was listed as certified.
Unfortunately, there are even a few pitfalls to interpreting the certification reports - one of the
things to be aware of is what I call "padding the list".
Some companies
“play the certification game” by paying separately to have individual VOCs tested and
listed,
even though, if the VOC Reduction group is listed, all of the
individual VOCs on the NSF table below are already covered and do not need to be re-listed.
Check out the NSF site below, and use them as one of your guides to selecting a reliable
product. The site has on-line comparisons of many of the products they certify.
NSF
International Mission statement - Behind the NSF Mark is an
independent, not-for-profit organization called NSF International. For over 50
years NSF has been committed to public health safety and protection of the
environment by developing standards, by providing education and by providing
third-party conformity assessment services while representing the interest of
all stakeholders.
The NSF site provides an on-line comparison of water filtration
units and bottled water products that are certified by NSF.
NSF Video: Choosing a Drinking Water Treatment Unit
You can review certified Drinking Water
Treatment Units.
The NSF Standards that apply to water filters are # 42 and
# 53. To use the guide, for water
treatment units, either enter
a company name you are interested in
investigating or scroll
to the bottom of the page and select either the
product type
(counter top filter, under counter filter, etc.) or the
product
standard (42, 44, 53, etc.).
You can look up certified bottled water products by brand
name, product type, etc. at Bottled
Water and Packaged Ice.
NSF
Drinking Water Standards
There are currently six ANSI/NSF standards relating to water
filtration and treatment devices, each one designed for a specific type
of product.
STANDARD 42: Drinking Water Treatment Devices - Aesthetic Effects
STANDARD 44: Cation Exchange Water Softeners
STANDARD 53: Drinking Water Treatment Devices - Health Effects
STANDARD 55: Ultraviolet Microbiological Water Treatment Systems
STANDARD 58: Reverse Osmosis Drinking Water Treatment Systems
STANDARD 62: Drinking Water Distillation Systems
|
|